| 1 | Booster Gold |
| 2 | Flaming Carrot |
| 3 | Doctor Strange |
| 4 | Elongated Man |
| 5 | Rorschach |
| 6 | Black Panther |
| 7 | Cable |
| 8 | X-Man |
| 9 | The Fat Fury (accept Herbie) |
| 10 | Zatanna |
| 11 | Captain Marvel (do not accept Shazam!) |
| 12 | The Vision |
| 13 | Power Man/Luke Cage |
| 14 | Nova |
| 15 | Green Lantern (Kyle Rayner version) |
| 16 | Johnny Thunder |
| 17 | Green Arrow |
| 18 | Scarlet Witch |
| 19 | Hellboy |
| 20 | Silver Surfer |
| 21 | She-Hulk |
| 22 | Hourman |
| 23 | Doctor Manhattan |
| 24 | The Tick |
| 25 | The Wasp |
| 26 | Bizarro |
| 27 | Thanos |
| 28 | Hate-Monger |
| 29 | Chairface Chippendale |
| 30 | Doctor Octopus |
| 31 | Darkseid |
| 32 | Mole Man |
| 33 | The Cheetah |
| 34 | MODOK |
| 35 | The Penguin |