| Song | Original Artist | Cover Artist | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New York, New York | Frank Sinatra OR Liza Minelli | Reel Big Fish |
| 2 | New York, New York | Frank Sinatra OR Liza Minelli | Cat Power |
| 3 | My Doorbell | The White Stripes | Jack Johnson |
| 4 | Mushaboom | Feist | Bright Eyes |
| 5 | My Humps | Black Eyed Peas | Alanis Morrisette |
| 6 | Mad World | Tear For Fears | Gary Jules |
| 7 | Fell In Love | The White Stripes | Joss Stone |
| 8 | Drift Away | Dobie Gray | Bruce Springsteen |
| 9 | War Pigs | Black Sabbath | Cake |
| 10 | All That She Wants | Ace of Bass | The Kooks |
| 11 | Crazy | Gnarls Barkley | The Raconteurs |
| 12 | Science Fiction Double Feature | Rocky Horror Picture Show | Me First and the Gimme Gimmes |
| 13 | Beat It | Michael Jackson | Fallout Boy |
| 14 | Stronger | Kanye West | 30 Seconds to Mars |
| 15 | I Can't Get No Satisfaction | The Rolling Stones | PJ Harvey and Bjork (give credit for either) |
| 16 | Everything In Its Right Place | Radiohead | Osunlade ft. Erro (give them anything at all) |
| 17 | Mr. Blue Sky | Electric Light Orchestra | Lily Allen |
| 18 | Golden Skans | The Klaxons | Kaiser Chiefs |
| 19 | Cry Me A River | Justin Timberlake | UVA Hullabahoos (A Cappella) |
| 20 | Voodoo Child | Jimi Hendrix | Angelique Kidjo |
| 21 | I'm A Cuckoo | Belle and Sebastien | The Avalanches |
| 22 | Bridge Over Troubled Waters | Simon and Garfunkle | Aretha Franklin |
| 23 | Float On | Modest Mouse | Ben Lee |